The decision in Caddick and another v Whitsand Bay Holiday Park Ltd (2015) gives useful guidance on the factors to consider when determining whether a holiday park home (or other structure) is a building or a chattel.
The case was heard through First-Tier Tribunal Property Chamber, and subsequently the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) on appeal. It concerned whether a holiday park home was a dwelling for the purposes of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. The tenants had a 125 year lease and wished to claim the service charge protections set out in the Act.
There must be a letting of a “dwelling” for the service charge protections to apply. Section 38 of the Act defines a dwelling as: “a building or part of a building occupied or intended to be occupied as a separate dwelling …”.
So the issue in this case was whether the holiday park home was a building. Without a building there is no dwelling for the purposes of the Act. Without a dwelling the occupant cannot invoke the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 to refer service charge disputes to the Lands Chamber.
The First-Tier Tribunal Property Chamber decided the home was not a building and this was supported in obiter on appeal. It was concluded that the holiday park home was a chattel, and not a building, because the structure could be removed from the land without causing material damage to the structure.
There may be instances where a holiday park home is a building. Each case is a matter of fact and degree. The Lands Chamber referred to the House of Lords decision in Elitestone Ltd v Morris (1997) where their lordships decided a bungalow was a fixture attached to the land and not a chattel. This was on the basis that removal of the structure from the land would occasion its destruction. By contrast, in this case the experts agreed removal was possible without demolition.
Our articles explained
All our articles and blogs are correct on the date they’re published but please don’t rely on them as legal advice. If you’d like to speak to us about your own legal requirements, please contact one of our expert lawyers.