We've pulled together recent court decisions that may be of interest in this litigation cases review.
Use of AI by litigants in person
It is not acceptable for litigants, including those without legal representation, to use GenAI to create documents for the court without checking them to ensure they are accurate and contain only relevant points. They should not attempt to place the onus of these documents – here a 300 page skeleton argument – on the opposing party, nor should they correspond excessively and repetitiously with the court (Hancox v Sutherland).
Pre-judgment interest on costs
Costs orders cannot require one party to provide for payment of all or part of a success fee payable by another party under a conditional fee agreement (CFA). This does not prevent a court from awarding pre-judgment interest on costs under CPR 44.2(6)(g) to a party litigating under a CFA with a contingent liability to compensate their lawyers for providing legal services on credit. The discretion to award interest on costs is large and it was appropriate here to use it to compensate the claimants for the loss of the time value of their money (Municipio de Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Ltd).
Privilege
Legal advice privilege applies not only to legal advice on questions of law but may extend to advice as to what may prudently and sensibly be done within a relevant legal context. Privilege may apply even where the advice addresses commercial considerations or has commercial consequences. Where the author of a potentially privileged document wears two "hats", acting both as a legal adviser and in some other capacity, the document can only be privileged if the author was acting as a lawyer when they prepared the document in question (Hogan Lovells Cadwalader International LLP v HMRC).
Invalid deed
Execution rules for deeds must be complied with. Here a company wanted to give a limited power of attorney to another company: statute required this to be done by deed. Where a company executes a deed through one director, section 44(2)(b) of the Companies Act 2006 requires a witness to be physically present to watch the director sign and to sign the deed themselves. The witness had not signed the deed in this case and so it was invalid. The fact that the parties had treated the document as a valid deed could not remedy the situation (3Kings Holdings Ltd v TCF 1 GP Ltd).
Part 36 offer
Where there is a split trial, CPR 36.16 allows a judge following a hearing of preliminary issues to be told about the existence of a Part 36 offer but not the terms of the offer. An issue arose here as to whether the court could be told the date of the defendant’s earliest Part 36 offer. The successful claimant wished to seek its costs down to the date 21 days after the offer. The court held that the date of an offer is not part of its terms and that accordingly it could be told the relevant date (Essendi UK Hotels 2 Ltd v London Property Company Ltd).
For more information, please get in touch with Miranda Whiteley.
Our content explained
Every piece of content we create is correct on the date it’s published but please don’t rely on it as legal advice. If you’d like to speak to us about your own legal requirements, please contact one of our expert lawyers.