Earlier this month, the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government launched a consultation on proposed reforms to the Crichel Down Rules (the non-statutory guidance governing the disposal of surplus land acquired by, or under the threat of, compulsory purchase), aimed at “consolidating, modernising, simplifying, speeding-up and reducing the administrative costs of the…process” (proposed 2026 rules).
The proposed 2026 rules narrow the circumstances in which the obligation to offer back arises, introduces clearer time limits, simplify the exceptions, and streamline the administrative process for disposing authorities. We set out below the key changes.
The proposed reforms are significant because they don't simply modernise the drafting of the Crichel Down Rules. Taken together, they would reduce the circumstances in which surplus land needs to be offered back and, where an offer back is required, accelerate the process considerably. The central policy principle survives, but the balance arguably shifts towards enabling public bodies to deal with surplus land more quickly.
Expectation the Crichel Down Rules will be followed
While the Crichel Down Rules remain non-statutory guidance, the proposed 2026 rules now expressly provide that local authorities and other statutory bodies with compulsory purchase powers, or those who hold land which has been compulsorily purchased, are “expected to follow” the rules. This replaces the existing wording under which compliance with the Crichel Down Rules by local authorities is “recommended”.
This subtle change of language is noteworthy. While the government is simplifying the operation of the Crichel Down Rules, it's also expecting compliance. Disposing authorities may therefore find that the proposed 2026 rules become easier to apply but potentially harder to disregard.
Compulsory purchase procedures must have been initiated
Under the Crichel Down Rules, a voluntary acquisition may be treated as occurring under threat of compulsion simply because the acquiring authority had compulsory purchase powers available to it. Under the proposed 2026 rules, the authority must:
Have had power to acquire the land compulsorily at the time of the voluntary acquisition
Have initiated compulsory purchase procedures*
*Appendix A to the proposed 2026 rules specifies when procedures are treated as having been initiated. This includes steps such as the publication and service of notice of the making of a CPO.
This represents an important narrowing of the Crichel Down Rules. The mere existence of compulsory purchase powers will no longer be enough to bring a voluntary acquisition within the scope of the obligation to offer back. The point at which negotiations and a voluntary sale take place in the CPO process may therefore assume greater significance.
Application to severed land
The proposed 2026 rules extend to severed land acquired as a result of service of a counter notice pursuant to Schedule 2A of the Compulsory Purchase Act 1965 or Schedule A1 to the Compulsory Purchase (Vesting Declarations) Act 1981, in addition to blighted land.
This is a useful clarification given that the acquisition of severed land arises as a consequence of the compulsory acquisition process even though the acquiring authority may not originally have intended to acquire it. Its express inclusion is therefore consistent with the underlying fairness principle of the Crichel Down Rules.
Qualifying disposals
The proposed 2026 rules apply only to freehold disposals and make clear that they don't apply to land acquired by adverse possession. The existing application of the Crichel Down Rules to the creation or disposal of leasehold interests exceeding seven years, including arrangements capable of exceeding seven years, is proposed to be removed.
The removal of longer leasehold disposals from the Crichel Down Rules could have practical significance for public-sector estate management. It potentially gives disposing bodies considerably greater flexibility to grant long leases of surplus property without first undertaking the offer back procedure.
For dwellings with sitting tenants, the existing order of priority for offer back is reversed. The freehold is to be offered first to the former owner, subject to the tenant's continued occupation. If the former owner declines, it's then offered to the sitting tenant.
The proposed 2026 rules also clarify that where a former owner was a business, the obligation to offer back is limited to that named business where it continues to legally exist as a business entity, and does not apply to directors, shareholders, parent companies or successor companies). This should remove some of the potentially difficult questions about corporate succession that can arise where many years have passed between compulsory acquisition and disposal. The trade-off is that corporate restructuring may cause the practical benefit of the Crichel Down Rules to disappear even where substantially the same underlying business continues.
Shorter time horizon for obligation to offer back
Proposed 2026 rules introduce clearer long-stop periods for the general obligation to offer:
Agricultural land: no obligation to offer back where the land becomes surplus and available for disposal more than 25 years after the date of acquisition by the disposing authority
Non-agricultural land: no obligation to offer back where the land becomes surplus and available for disposal more than 15 years after the date of acquisition by the disposing authority
The proposal to introduce long-stop dates recognises the practical difficulties of applying the Crichel Down Rules decades after an acquisition, when ownership structures, land uses and surrounding development may have changed considerably. For disposing authorities with historic landholdings, the 15-year limit for non-agricultural land could ultimately remove a significant administrative hurdle to disposal.
The timetable for the offer back process is also proposed to be shortened. Where the former owner’s address is known, the period allowed for the former owner to indicate an intention to purchase is proposed to be reduced from two months to one month. The period within which terms (other than value) are to be agreed is similarly proposed to be reduced from two months to one month. The subsequent six week period for negotiating price remains.
These changes illustrate perhaps most clearly the balance the government is seeking to strike. They should reduce the period during which a disposing authority is effectively unable to progress an alternative disposal, but a one month response period is relatively demanding for a former owner who may need to establish the commercial case for reacquiring the land, obtain valuation and legal advice and secure funding. Former owners receiving an offer will therefore need to act quickly.
Where the former owner’s address is unknown, the disposing authority is expected to use reasonable endeavours to obtain a present address. Examples of reasonable endeavours include contacting the former owner’s professional representative, reviewing Land Registry records and searching the internet and accessing tracing software. The proposed 2026 rules make clear however, that the disposing authority is not expected to undertake extensive enquiries which could generate an unreasonable amount of additional work.
If a current address cannot be identified, the disposing authority need only place notice on its website and on or near the land for a period of three weeks. The existing requirements to advertise through the London Gazette, Estates Gazette, local newspapers and, for agricultural land, Farmers Weekly are removed. The requirement to notify adjoining landowners of the proposed disposal is also removed from this stage of the process. The administrative burden on disposing authorities would be reduced, but a site notice, and website notice in particular, may in practice be less likely to come to a former owner’s attention than the existing suite of advertisements.
Where a disposing authority determines that land falls within an exception to the offer back requirement, the Proposed 2026 Rules also remove the existing requirement to notify the former owner of that decision. Instead, the authority is expected to record the decision and its reasons. The importance of good internal record keeping consequently increases, as while a disposing authority may no longer have to communicate its decision to the former owner, it should retain a clear audit trail explaining why it concluded that an exception applied, particularly given the non-statutory but public law nature of the Rules.
Market value
The proposed 2026 rules introduce express definitions of “market value” and “current market value” providing greater certainty when determining the price at which land is offered back.
“Market value” means the ‘best price reasonably obtainable for the surplus land’, which is equivalent to the definition of ‘market value’ in the RICS Appraisal and Valuation Manual (the red book) but includes any “special value” which may be available from a special purchaser. This may include, for example, additional value attributable to the land because of its potential to be amalgamated with adjoining land, protect existing assets or secure operational efficiencies. “Current market value” is the market value on the date the disposing authority first commences negotiations with the former owner.
The express recognition of special purchaser value is important. The offer back principle does not give the former owner an entitlement to reacquire the land at an artificially discounted price. Where the land has particular value to that former owner because, for example, it can be reunited with adjoining land which the former owner still owns, that additional value may feed into the price payable.
Exemptions – material change of character
The proposed 2026 rules clarify the circumstances in which land will be exempt from the offer back requirement because there has been a material change in its character since the date of acquisition. The of ‘date of acquisition’ for this purpose is now the earlier of:
The date of the conveyance, transfer or vesting declaration
Where known, the date on which the disposing authority first occupied the land prior to formal acquisition
The proposed 2026 rules make clear that material change is to be assessed by reference to the whole of the surplus land being disposed of, rather than individual parcels. This whole-site approach should discourage an overly granular analysis.
Whether a material change has occurred remains a matter of judgement for the disposing authority, but the proposed 2026 rules provide further examples to assist, including the installation of infrastructure or services on, over or under the land, and where the land is no longer capable of its previous use without works being undertaken to restore it.
Conclusion
The proposed 2026 rules retain the underlying principle that former owners should generally have the first opportunity to repurchase land which they were compelled to sell (or which was acquired from them compulsorily) where that land is no longer required.
However, the proposed changes are more than a procedural tidy-up. The combination of narrower eligibility for offer back, fixed long-stop dates, shorter offer response periods, fewer advertising and notification requirements and clearer exceptions would give public bodies materially greater freedom to bring surplus land forward for disposal.
While that potentially makes the proposed 2026 rules better suited to a modern public sector estate, the protection afforded to former owners becomes narrower and, once an offer to sell back is made, considerably more time sensitive.
The real question raised by the Consultation is therefore whether the proposals have struck the right balance between the two objectives at the heart of the Crichel Down Rules: fairness to those whose land was acquired compulsorily (or under threat of compulsion) and the efficient release of public land which is no longer needed.
The Consultation on the proposed 2026 rules runs until 6 January 2027.
(View the rules against the September 2024 version)
Our content explained
Every piece of content we create is correct on the date it’s published but please don’t rely on it as legal advice. If you’d like to speak to us about your own legal requirements, please contact one of our expert lawyers.