Existing clients

Log in to your client extranet for free matter information, know-how and documents.

Client login

Staff

Mills & Reeve system for employees.

Staff Login
16 Nov 2026
2 minutes read

Resisting demands: Why evidence matters

In Doubtfire v Horrell, the High Court considered the evidential threshold for setting aside a statutory demand where a guarantor relied on disputed liability and substantial cross-claims arising from connected commercial dealings. The set aside-application was dismissed.

The statutory demand was based on a personal guarantee given by Richard Doubtfire for a loan made to his company. He sought to set it aside, arguing that the guarantee had been obtained by duress or undue influence and relying on cross-claims in defamation and unlawful means conspiracy.

The interesting point for practitioners is how firmly the court looked past the allegations and at the evidence actually available to support them. Although a set-aside application should not become a mini trial, that does not mean an asserted dispute automatically gets over the line. The court can test it against the contemporaneous documents and ask whether, taking the debtor's case at its highest, there is really a substantial dispute or genuine and serious cross-claim.

Here, the documents mattered. The debtor was an experienced businessman who had received independent legal advice before signing the guarantee and had subsequently agreed that it should remain in force. His allegations of duress and undue influence were not supported by evidence capable of showing that illegitimate pressure operated when the guarantee was entered into.

There was a similar problem with the cross-claims. The defamation claim lacked evidence of serious harm and had not been quantified. The conspiracy claim also failed to establish the necessary combination, intention, causation and loss. In particular, the claimed £1.25 million loss was unsupported by evidence from which the court could value the chance allegedly lost.

The commercial takeaway is straightforward: statutory demand applications are not trials, but simply raising factual issues will not be enough. The court will scrutinise whether the issues raised have real substance. If a debtor wants to rely on a dispute or cross-claim, it needs to arrive with a properly evidenced case, particularly where quantum is critical to getting above the statutory threshold.

Doubtfire v Horrell [2026] EWHC 2173 (Ch)

Our content explained

Every piece of content we create is correct on the date it’s published but please don’t rely on it as legal advice. If you’d like to speak to us about your own legal requirements, please contact one of our expert lawyers.